STAR TREK: BEYOND THE FINAL FRONTIER
"We were ordinary people in extraordinary situations going where no man or woman had gone before."
- Nichelle Nichols
Leonard Nimoy had the unenviable job of thanking "the most loyal fans in the history of television" as he hosted this documentary about the mass sale of Star Trek props by Paramount. It is not worthy of his time, as the few pieces of Trek trivia, while enjoyable, are sadly undercut by a production team that had little respect for its subject and even less for the people it interviewed.
The galactic fire sale was a big press item at the time, but right away it leaves a bad taste in the fan's mouth: Paramount as some kind of benevolent master passing out the props to the fans? Or is it simply that Paramount wanted to clear warehouse space and thought this might bring in extra dough? Yeah.
There's some honesty to the reminscing, as always coming from George Takei. He tells us the original crew was miffed when they heard there would a Next Generation, especially James Doohan. Takei has rarely minced words about the uglier parts of Trek history, despite his role as standard bearer for the Trek legacy. I personally watched him trounce some idiotic fan shouting about the brilliance of DOCTOR WHO during Takei's speech at Archon a few years ago, but he also has been honest about the parts that don't make Paramount press releases.
Elsewhere, Marina Sirtis and Jonathan Frakes remarked on how poorly the first season of TNG was received, fans' resistance and honest criticism of the writing. We forgot, didn't we? We forgot that it wasn't always beloved.
A few prime moments:
• "I was asked in the first year, how does it feel to be stepping into the shoes of Captain Kirk? I had the presence of mind to say, 'Excuse me, but Captain Kirk is still filling his shoes very, very adequately... In three seasons, what Bill achieved, what he established with that character, I think, towers over everything else. Just remember that I said that, Bill, the next time we decide who's paying for dinner."
-- Patrick Stewart.
• "You're writing morality plays, and you put it in the 23rd century," Nichols said she told creator Gene Roddenberry. "And he sat back and he roared! And then he said, 'Shh! They haven't figured that out yet.' And I thought that was the most wonderful thing, because then I realized these were the adventures and stories he wanted to tell of the human condition."
• And then there was the humor: the actors griping about their costumes: "No pockets!" exclaimed Frakes, Armin Shimerman and Avery Brooks. Sirtis had some well-deserved gripes about her first-season "cosmic cheerleader outfit." I'm going to be hearing that in my head the next time I watch that episode. Frakes revealed the "Picard Maneuver," where they tugged their uniforms straight when they sat down.
Takei's pick for worst uniform: the monochrome Spandex suits of STAR TREK: THE MOTIONLESS PICTURE that apparently required a dresser to dismantle for the actors to go to the bathroom. He claims they refused to do another movie unless the uniforms were changed.
• Trivia Point: The Cardassians have funky shoulders because Marc Alaimo, who played the original Cardassian, had a long neck and the makeup director didn't know what else to do with it.
Those are pretty much the highlights. I got more fun trivia from Wikipedia - did you know that Stewart, Jonathan Frakes, LeVar Burton and Michael Dorn are in a band together called the Sunspots? - but if you're a props geek, knock yourself out.
Just brace yourself for utter silliness, and not in the fun way. When they move a ship model, the monkeys directing this schlock intercut turbulence shots from the series. Ha. Ha. That's funny?
And there's the requisite "let's make fun of the fans" bit seeking the weirdest and goofiest of them and intercutting "reaction" shots from the series. The disrespect just drives me mad, because after all these years, they still don't Get It. At least the producers of this documentary don't. STILL.
Take a line from Wil Wheaton: These worlds do not exist without fans. As Wheaton revealed, Jonathan Frakes bought his first house with the money he made at conventions. Paramount has made billions off the fans, and they deserve better than yet another mockumentary.
But the actors get it, at least, most of them do. "They come from all walks of life," Nichols said. "They're not some imbecilic people running around who need to get a life.* They are human beings of great quality." A gracious statement, which is immediately undercut by the directors by showing an amateurish masquerade act.
And thank God, Gene "Rod" Roddenberry, son of the Great Bird himself, gets it better than most: "You've got Star Trek fans that may dress up as Klingons and Vulcans and other weird things. But you've got football fans who paint their faces and they've got their hats with the two beers on it. They're wearing a costume."**
BEYOND THE FINAL FRONTIER manages to make the auction itself somewhat suspenseful. To my surprise, Stewart did not "nick" the flute from one of his most famous episodes, "The Inner Life." The flute, which went for $40,000, plays an integral part in the story and reappears a few times later in the series. Stewart then reveals that "it doesn't play. It's not a real flute." Heh.
The model for the original Enterprise is in the National Air and Space Museum (take that, snobs). None of the ship models went for less than six figures. Enterprise D, the most graceful, swanlike and aesthetically inspiring of the ship designs (in CultureGeek's opinion) went for $500,000. The auction broke records with more than $7 million, and clearly they had no idea what people would pay - Spock's silly headband from STAR TREK IV was estimated at $500 and went for $5,400.
The documentary tries to cast the sale as a good thing. The cast members themselves say they'd rather devoted fans own and care for these pieces of television history than see them thrown away, and I agree with them.
But I dare you to watch long-time Trek guru Mike Okuda uncrate the full-size model of Enterprise D and slap a price tag on it without your heart breaking. Almost as much as listening to Nichols and Takei reminisce about the late James Doohan and DeForest Kelley, gentlemen whose fire and grace gave us characters we remember forty years later.
Because, in essence, what this sale and poorly-directed documentary means is that this is over, the wonderful adventures and heroes of your childhood will never fly again. Even if J.J. Abrams is successful in his bid to start over with STAR TREK XI, the part we loved so much is over. Kobayashi Maru.
Except on DVDs. Available for $69.99 a season.
* Ouch. Shatner felt that one.
** My theater history professor had a marvelous theory comparing the body-painting, chanting football fans with arcane religious rites, but that's another column.