BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER, Nos. 9-12
Dark Horse Comics
It's hard to say how I feel about Buffy's comic turn. From the beginning, I loved it in spite of myself. It was quintessential Joss Whedon writing, the characters speaking and acting just like the old days. They almost seemed to have recovered the rapport of Best of Buffy, and at first Buffy seemed to have shed the poor-little-me that nearly killed the series for me in her post-death life.
Only in the Whedonverse does "post-death life" make sense.
It's still good. Of course it is, Brian K. Vaughan is no slouch and Joss himself is back for the occasional issue. But a few things are driving me crazier than a Renfield with no flies:
• Willow's "big reveal" that she feels guilty about Tara. That she chose Buffy's life over Tara's and got Tara killed. Um, what? We were there for all that, folks, and pretty much Warren Mears got Tara killed, by shooting her while trying to shoot Buffy. Willow went evil, killed people, nearly destroyed the world and wore some absolutely dreadful sweaters, but the one thing she feels guilty about is the one thing she DIDN'T do? Joss, please try harder.
• The resurgence of Buffy as the whiny superhero bugs me, and it's Joss doing it. Buffy's self-involvement is legendary, but of course she's the Chosen One, so a little self-involvement is expected. The problem is, heroes don't whine. You'd think having a private army of 500 Slayers would take the onus off being the Chosen One, but Buffy's still giving us lines like, "They all leave, even my friends, sooner or later everybody realizes there's something wrong, something wrong with me, or around me, or..."
Ow! Joss, that hurt! There's a reason we hated Season Seven, yanno. We like superpowered Buffy in her tough armor and leading the fight as she always has. Whiny, neurotic Buffy fell into the Hellmouth. Leave her there.
• Dawn. The problem with Dawn has been the same since her arc was resolved at the end of Season Five: what to do with the MacGuffin after the fight is over? Once everyone stopped fighting over Dawn, she was just a whiny teenager with "I Am a Potential Hostage" stamped on her forehead.
Comics have not found a use for Dawn, so she's been magically "blown up" to giant size and stuck in the barn. I'm sure there is a point to this besides some admittedly cool visuals of the lounging lady giant in the Scottish castle. But it's up to issue 12 now and there seems to be no actual resolution.
Here's a hint, Joss: Dawn was the Key, and even if she wasn't, some folks have managed to serve the forces of righteousness quite well without superpowers. Exhibit A: Xander Harris. So shrink her back down and give her a job, or kill her. Or both. We know you can do it. You're JOSS.
• And here it is: Buffy has a one-night (so far) stand. With Satsu. A woman.
I went round and round about this, because I honestly like the idea of a bisexual or lesbian heroine. Heaven knows there are few enough of them in comics, fewer still that aren't written like the fantasies of fifteen-year-old boys. This plot twist made headlines in the industry, but most reviewers shrugged it off as, "Well, Joss has done it before."
Yes. And honestly, that's what bugs me about it. We've already been here, with Willow. A girl who is entirely heterosexual without the slightest indication of bisexuality, until Joss suddenly wrote in a girlfriend. He pulled it off with taste and dignity, because he's Joss. But it always struck me as a bit of a retcon, because Willow never had the slightest hint of being interested in girls before - and she was friends with BUFFY. And Cordelia. Fairly hot women, or so I've been told.
Then Willow was completely lesbian. She had no interest in men at all. Again, something I might have found more realistic if we hadn't seen her have fully-developed, loving and even sexual relationships with Xander and Oz. (Okay, with Oz. She and Xander never knocked boots. But the implication is they did a lot more than hold hands.) I always would have liked this plot twist if pre-Tara Willow* had gradually shown interest in the occasional girl - and don't say Joss doesn't plan that far ahead, because he was foreshadowing Buffy's Season-Five death in Season Three. And I would have preferred that Willow became bisexual, thereby expanding her character and still maintaining some continuity.
All that set aside. Here we are again. Buffy, who was somewhat weirded out by Willow's coming-out and never indicated the slightest interest in any woman, suddenly falls into bed with Satsu. Who is a very nice, sweet girl, but I have reread these issues several times and I still don't see a reason for Buffy's attraction. Especially given the, you know, heterosexuality. Even Satsui comments, "I know you didn't just turn gay all of a sudden." It's a fair question, and of course it devolves into Buffy's Insta-Insecurity instead of addressing the question.
Hey, the rest of that scene is hilarious. It's quintessential Whedonverse, and Xander... well, let's just say I could HEAR Nicholas Brendan saying those lines, okay? Imagine my surprise that the issue was written by Drew Goddard, not Joss.
But a retcon is still a retcon, and nobody's going to mistake it for anything else. The cynical comics reviewers say it's a ploy to drive up readership for the comic, much as they said about Willow's conversion during the series. I'm not that cynical, mostly because I know Joss isn't living and dying with this comic as he was, say, a certain space western well-beloved by us all. (Browncoats forever!)
There's plenty to love about Season 8. It has the right feel, the right art - Georges Jeanty perfectly captures the characters, to the point where we recognize even one-shot guest stars - and Joss hasn't lost a bit of his touch. But I hope for more from it than rehashing the old stuff over and over.
So. Who wants to take bets on how Satsu dies?
* And don't bring up Wishverse Willow. Alternate reality, doesn't count. Also, the whole evil=bisexual thing I found to be rather skeevy. Most bisexuals are not, after all, evil.